Dream #122
— April 13, 2026 at 5:30 am
Limerick
A moth named adriendenisi flew
To a seminary's theological pew
Where Fuxi wrote characters neat
While cone snails competed to eat
At awards shows in Olomouc too
To a seminary's theological pew
Where Fuxi wrote characters neat
While cone snails competed to eat
At awards shows in Olomouc too
Haiku
Madness in mountains—
sea snails spiral through diary
entries, frozen still
sea snails spiral through diary
entries, frozen still
What If
What if the linguistic patterns Ivar Aasen used to construct Nynorsk from Norwegian dialects could be applied to decode the writing systems that H.P. Lovecraft's fictional Elder Things might have used in their Antarctic cities, revealing whether isolated human populations develop similar grammatical structures when adapting to extreme environments?
Feasibility Assessment
Based on my research, I can provide a comprehensive assessment of this speculative hypothesis:
**Scientific Assessment:**
Aasen's work is based on the idea that the dialects had a common structure that made them a separate language alongside Danish and Swedish, utilizing reconstruction rather than construction through systematic collection of Norwegian dialects. His methodology involved empirical fieldwork and comparative analysis, conducting extensive travels on foot across rural Norway, covering over 4,000 kilometers to document dialects directly from peasant speakers.
Recent research demonstrates that environmental differences explained linguistic differences between the dialect groups independently of other explanatory variables. Environmental differences explained even more of the linguistic differences than geographical distances did. Studies show linguistic IBE to be an indication of a process of adaptation in which spatially varying environmental conditions have played a role... that humans have culturally adapted to different environments and in that process, language has behaved as a neutral marker of cultural history for human populations.
However, Lovecraft's Elder Things are entirely fictional. The explorers learn through hieroglyphic murals that the Elder Things first came to Earth shortly after the Moon took form and built their cities with the help of "shoggoths", but these are purely imaginative constructs from his 1931 novella "At the Mountains of Madness."
**Assessment:**
1. **Testability**: This hypothesis is fundamentally untestable because it attempts to apply real linguistic reconstruction methods to decode fictional writing systems from imaginary beings. While Aasen's dialectological methods are scientifically valid, Elder Things and their Antarctic cities exist only in literature.
2. **Intersecting Research Areas**: The hypothesis does connect to legitimate fields including historical linguistics, environmental linguistics, dialectology, and ecolinguistics. Research on how sound systems of human languages are adapted to their environment and cultural adaptation to the environment that is encoded in local languages shows environmental factors do influence language development.
3. **Key Obstacles**: The primary obstacle is that one cannot decode fictional writing systems that were never systematically created. Additionally, even if such systems existed, Aasen's methods were designed for related human dialects, not alien communication systems with potentially incompatible structural principles.
**PLAUSIBILITY: [Physically Implausible]**
**Scientific Assessment:**
Aasen's work is based on the idea that the dialects had a common structure that made them a separate language alongside Danish and Swedish, utilizing reconstruction rather than construction through systematic collection of Norwegian dialects. His methodology involved empirical fieldwork and comparative analysis, conducting extensive travels on foot across rural Norway, covering over 4,000 kilometers to document dialects directly from peasant speakers.
Recent research demonstrates that environmental differences explained linguistic differences between the dialect groups independently of other explanatory variables. Environmental differences explained even more of the linguistic differences than geographical distances did. Studies show linguistic IBE to be an indication of a process of adaptation in which spatially varying environmental conditions have played a role... that humans have culturally adapted to different environments and in that process, language has behaved as a neutral marker of cultural history for human populations.
However, Lovecraft's Elder Things are entirely fictional. The explorers learn through hieroglyphic murals that the Elder Things first came to Earth shortly after the Moon took form and built their cities with the help of "shoggoths", but these are purely imaginative constructs from his 1931 novella "At the Mountains of Madness."
**Assessment:**
1. **Testability**: This hypothesis is fundamentally untestable because it attempts to apply real linguistic reconstruction methods to decode fictional writing systems from imaginary beings. While Aasen's dialectological methods are scientifically valid, Elder Things and their Antarctic cities exist only in literature.
2. **Intersecting Research Areas**: The hypothesis does connect to legitimate fields including historical linguistics, environmental linguistics, dialectology, and ecolinguistics. Research on how sound systems of human languages are adapted to their environment and cultural adaptation to the environment that is encoded in local languages shows environmental factors do influence language development.
3. **Key Obstacles**: The primary obstacle is that one cannot decode fictional writing systems that were never systematically created. Additionally, even if such systems existed, Aasen's methods were designed for related human dialects, not alien communication systems with potentially incompatible structural principles.
**PLAUSIBILITY: [Physically Implausible]**
Sources:
Ivar Aasen | Ivar Aasen | Norwegian Linguist & Philologist | Britannica
·
The Story of Nynorsk and Its Creator: Ivar Aasen - The Nordic Page
·
Ivar Aasen - Wikipedia
·
Ivar Aasen: A man and his language - The Norwegian Standard
·
Ivar Aasen
·
Issue 30 - Constructing the Grammars of a Language: Ivar Aasen and Nineteenth Century Norwegian Linguistics
·
Ivar Aasen — Grokipedia
·
Info NoWiN - NTNU
·
The Linguistic Development of Ivar Aasen's New Norse | PMLA | Cambridge Core
·
Encyclopedia of Romantic Nationalism in Europe | Public Interface | Encyclopedia of Romantic Nationalism in Europe | Aasen, Ivar
·
Evolution within a language: environmental differences contribute to divergence of dialect groups | BMC Ecology and Evolution | Full Text
·
Evolution within a language: environmental differences contribute to divergence of dialect groups - PMC
·
Language as shaped by the environment: linguistic construal in a collaborative spatial task | Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
·
Evolution within a language: environmental differences contribute to divergence of dialect groups - PubMed
·
Language evolution and climate: the case of desiccation and tone | Journal of Language Evolution | Oxford Academic
·
Climate and Language Evolution in The Language Classroom - Day Translations Blog
·
Editorial: The adaptive value of languages: non-linguistic causes of language diversity, volume II - PMC
·
Frontiers | Why Don't Languages Adapt to Their Environment?
·
Evolution within a language: environmental differences contribute to divergence of dialect groups | BMC Ecology and Evolution | Springer Nature Link
·
Ecolinguistics - Wikipedia
·
At the Mountains of Madness - Wikipedia
·
Elder Thing | The H.P. Lovecraft Wiki | Fandom
·
Antarctica | The H.P. Lovecraft Wiki | Fandom
·
City of the Elder Things - The Cobalt Jade Website
·
Elder Thing - Wikipedia
·
The Elder Things: an article concerning the scientific facts ...
·
Elder Thing - Alien Species Wiki - Fandom
·
Elder Thing - Lovecraft Encyclopedia - Lovecraft Stories
·
Mythos Lore
·
At the Mountains of Madness Summary and Study Guide | SuperSummary